Try 30 days of free premium.

Edit Requests


JuanArango wrote 6 years ago: 1

Thomas wrote:
This show is not even allowed per our policy for non-curated webshows. It should be deleted...

It does not meet our mandatory rule to list at least two crew credits.

I think they are listing those on Facebook or their Website

deleted wrote 6 years ago: 1

JuanArango wrote:
I think they are listing those on Facebook or their Website

No they are not. Neither fb and their website do list any crew credits. On top of that it is firstly released on Dumpert (A Dutch platform like YouTube.). It just doesn't match our policy.

It should be deleted. And you just add the show because you think it is listed over there without checking them first? That's debatable at first.

FHFbVB1Mkd3 wrote 6 years ago: 1

Well.. I knew it would be at least a close decision. But just to share my perspective..

The show must give credit to at least 1 cast member and at least 2 crew members

The main people behind it are known: Nick Toet - Camera & Editing (Host now too), Matthijs van den Beukel - Host (Former), René van Leeuwen - Host, Sylvana IJsselmuiden - Host.

Although truthfully I didn't realize this specific part (I did read the FAQ but missed that):

These credits must either be listed on-screen in the video itself, or specified in the video description.

I agree they are indeed not very formal with that. Technically they do share the names in the Youtube video description: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RYUEdU6PBqA (with links to Rene, Nick, Sylvana's instagram.) But I can see how that might not be formal/official enough. Btw, probably a lot of viewers watch it on Dumpert, but it is hosted on Youtube (and embedded on Dumpert.)

One of the credited cast- or crew members must be credited in another curated show

I assumed this is to make sure it is not a very tiny amateur show and DumpertReeten does have frequently pretty well known Dutch people at their show (just recent examples): 85 - Tim Hofman, 87 - Tim Haars & Bo Maerte, 90 - Geraldine Kemper, 98 - Henry van Loon, 100, 108, 113, 123, 131 - Tom Van Kalmthout & Yannick van de Velde, 101 - Maxim Hartman, 129 - Stefan Pop, etc.

Overall IMO this show seems appropriate enough to be on this site. But I am not trying to argue here, just sharing my perspective and will fully respect if it's not the case :)

deleted wrote 6 years ago: 1

FHFbVB1Mkd3 wrote:

The main people behind it are known: Nick Toet - Camera & Editing (Host now too), Matthijs van den Beukel - Host (Former), René van Leeuwen - Host, Sylvana IJsselmuiden - Host.

Our policy describes that this crediting should be either listed in video or by summary in which the series fail to attend to. On top of that you have listed three cast credits and only one crew, which per policy is still not matching either

So i am pretty sure it should still be scheduled to be deleted.

RyanK wrote 6 years ago: 1

Hello,

I tried adding season 3 Episode 4 to "to tell the Truth" https://www.tvmaze.com/shows/16041/to-tell-the-truth

However, it said "This entry already existed in the past, so it can only be re-created by a Trusted Contributor or higher."

The episode is airing July 8, 2018 https://abc.go.com/shows/to-tell-the-truth/episode-guide/season-03/4-episode-304

SilverSurfer wrote 6 years ago: 1

RyanK wrote:
Hello,

I tried adding season 3 Episode 4 to "to tell the Truth" https://www.tvmaze.com/shows/16041/to-tell-the-truth

However, it said "This entry already existed in the past, so it can only be re-created by a Trusted Contributor or higher."

The episode is airing July 8, 2018 https://abc.go.com/shows/to-tell-the-truth/episode-guide/season-03/4-episode-304

I added it. No, I added it. No, I added it. :)


JuanArango wrote 6 years ago: 1

FHFbVB1Mkd3 wrote:
Well.. I knew it would be at least a close decision. But just to share my perspective..

The main people behind it are known: Nick Toet - Camera & Editing (Host now too), Matthijs van den Beukel - Host (Former), René van Leeuwen - Host, Sylvana IJsselmuiden - Host.

Although truthfully I didn't realize this specific part (I did read the FAQ but missed that):

I agree they are indeed not very formal with that. Technically they do share the names in the Youtube video description: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RYUEdU6PBqA (with links to Rene, Nick, Sylvana's instagram.) But I can see how that might not be formal/official enough. Btw, probably a lot of viewers watch it on Dumpert, but it is hosted on Youtube (and embedded on Dumpert.)

I assumed this is to make sure it is not a very tiny amateur show and DumpertReeten does have frequently pretty well known Dutch people at their show (just recent examples): 85 - Tim Hofman, 87 - Tim Haars & Bo Maerte, 90 - Geraldine Kemper, 98 - Henry van Loon, 100, 108, 113, 123, 131 - Tom Van Kalmthout & Yannick van de Velde, 101 - Maxim Hartman, 129 - Stefan Pop, etc.

Overall IMO this show seems appropriate enough to be on this site. But I am not trying to argue here, just sharing my perspective and will fully respect if it's not the case :)

sorry it needs to be deleted :(

FHFbVB1Mkd3 wrote 6 years ago: 1

JuanArango wrote:
sorry it needs to be deleted :(

It's okay :) can understand need for policies/rules to maintain quality data.


animegirl wrote 6 years ago: 1

Hi,

I just wanted to ask a question. I moved an episode recap that someone wrote for Masterchef Canada Season 5 Episode 7 from the summary section to the Recap section. Was that ok for me to do so?

Please reply.

Thank you.


JuanArango wrote 6 years ago: 1

animegirl wrote:
Hi,

I just wanted to ask a question. I moved an episode recap that someone wrote for Masterchef Canada Season 5 Episode 7 from the summary section to the Recap section. Was that ok for me to do so?

Please reply.

Thank you.

Yes, sure :)

tnt wrote 6 years ago: 1

animegirl wrote:
Hi,

I just wanted to ask a question. I moved an episode recap that someone wrote for Masterchef Canada Season 5 Episode 7 from the summary section to the Recap section. Was that ok for me to do so?

Please reply.

Thank you.

Hmm, why do you think that it's a recap? Looks like a summary to me. Maybe too detailed to be a simple summary, but definitely too brief to be considered a recap.

Recap supposed to be a substitute for actually watching the episode, so in this case it should've mention a winning team at least. If you think that it contains some sort of a spoilers, you could've just edit them :)

Calamaz wrote 6 years ago: 1

Youtube Red has been renamed to Youtube Premium. Please change.

https://www.youtube.com/premium


gazza911 wrote 6 years ago: 1

Calamaz wrote:
Youtube Red has been renamed to Youtube Premium. Please change.

https://www.youtube.com/premium

Done, although I'm on my phone so it's harder to change the logo

tnt wrote 6 years ago: 1

gazza911 wrote:
Done, although I'm on my phone so it's harder to change the logo

Logo updated :)

deleted wrote 6 years ago: 1

tnt wrote:
Hmm, why do you think that it's a recap? Looks like a summary to me. Maybe too detailed to be a simple summary, but definitely too brief to be considered a recap.

Recap supposed to be a substitute for actually watching the episode, so in this case it should've mention a winning team at least. If you think that it contains some sort of a spoilers, you could've just edit them :)

It's too long to be an effective episode summary and it's not really a recap, so I guess it is 50/50 on this to decide :p

Try 30 days of free premium.